How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam
Dear Twitter,
You have done an incredible job of responding to a massive influx of new users, especially over the last 8 months. With growth reaching 1400% month over month, the need to react and support quickly has been critical, and for the most part I would say you have done so better than just about anybody else has that has seen such rapid growth on their platforms. With the recent roll out of Twitter lists you have also added value to the community by providing a tool that people can use to pull some signal out of all of the noise. Many are finding the lists as the place to discover and follow new people. Thank you for all of your work.
A new phenomenon has bubbled up from the user community, and it’s something that I would like you to take quick and decisive action on. Phishing scams have torn through Twitter on an almost daily basis for the last several weeks, with unsuspecting users clicking links and turning over their credentials. The results have been painful to deal with…I’m receiving dozens, and sometimes hundreds,of direct messages from real people (not bots) every single day with messages like, “hey. do this iq quiz for me http://quiz6545.info” and “i found y0u http://videos.twitter.shjjiwe.com/?vpgdzxiaq”. This is phishing that is perpetuating too rapidly and it’s starting to ruin the communication platform for me. Here is what needs to happen to fix this…
When I mention this on Twitter, most people reply by telling me that I shouldn’t follow spambots. I want to make something perfectly clear: this isn’t a problem with spambots, it’s a problem with real people clicking links that they shouldn’t, then handing over their username and password to a malicious site. That site then sends DMs about funny videos, weight loss and everything else under the sun to everybody that is following that person.
The Problem
The only way to prevent a DM from somebody is to unfollow them. I don’t want to unfollow these people, they are a valuable part of my community and I want to hear what they have to say. Granted, I’m disappointed that so many smart people have fallen for such obvious phishing scams, but I still want to be a part of their Twitter life. As it stands today, my only option is to unfollow them.
The Solution
Twitter already has the solution built in, although within a different area of the service: SMS. I have the ability to turn SMS notifications on and off globally, and when it is on, I select the individuals that I want to recieve updates from. SMS is not an “all or nothing” choice right now, and that is exactly what needs to happen with direct messages.
The Big Ask of Twitter
What I am asking is simple, although I know there are plenty of complicated actions behind the scenes if it were to happen: Please give your users the ability to turn direct messages on and off globally, and when on, give us the ability to select who can and cannot send us direct messages. I want to be able to follow people without them having the ability to send direct messages to me. I understand why this was built in to the original platform as most people that followed each other really did know each other personally. This is no longer the case, and so the platform must grown and move in the same direction as the community.
Thank you for your consideration Ev, Biz, Alex, Delbius and the rest of the crew. As the communications within Twitter have changed, so has the need for some of the original services to change with them. Keep up the good work!
Cheers,
Matt Singley (@mattsingley)
Additional comments powered by BackType


Alex Schleber said,
Matt, what you propose is well-intentioned, but I’m not sure that it would address the root causes of phishing and other DM spam issues:
1) Twitter DMs are mostly broken right now anyway. How? No search, no filter by user, no threading, no folders/tags, no archive/trash (most of this applies to FB too BTW). Why does it have to do a pop-up asking me if I want to delete permanently? Use 1 click, and just don’t delete permanently.
If you could trash DMs with 1 click, I suspect you wouldn’t care ass much about spammy ones flowing in. I am not saying that Twitter DMs need to become like full-fledged “private label” email, but it wouldn’t hurt to have them be a little more useful. FriendFeed DMs are a decent model (they have search, threading, & link expansion/inline images).
2) Twitter needs to do a better job of nipping the next wave of phishing DMs in the bud. They need to beef up their internal security filters on DMs (and regular tweets), monitor links, and shut down the forwarding once flagged. Bit.ly is already doing some of this I believe. So if Bit.ly takes care of their end, then Twitter could monitor the rest of the URL shorteners (bit.ly makes up what, 60% now?).
3) Some of these issues go a lot deeper than just Twitter. They are internet protocol issues (I’ve ranted against the idiocy of email SMTP not requiring sender authentication for years, asf.).
Trackback - Free Internation Call >> How to make free international call said,
,[...] mattsingley.com is one another nice source of information on this subject,[...]
The Direct Message Dilemma « SEO by Swaby – Utah SEO, SEM & Social Media said,
[...] Singley has a suggestion for Twitter, allow a separate controller for direct messages so a user can turn it off without unfollowing. [...]
Utah Web Design | Bent Design Studio said,
This is driving me crazy. Has anyone found a way to stop this! Thank you so much for this post. We really need to resolve this issue.
mattsingley said,
How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
mattsingley said,
How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
JustinHerman said,
Agreed 100% – this is getting bad RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
bigguyd said,
RT @mattsingley: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
clarkdever said,
Good Idea Matt! RT @mattsingley: How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
DansMobile said,
Agreed, Twitter are you listening? RT @mattsingley: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam[let's get this going folks] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
efalchuk said,
.@bigguyd RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix DM Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk (But is it safe to click on this?:)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Eliz_Castro said,
Twitter seriously needs to fix this spam problem, first getting weightloss now IQ messages all week long – http://bit.ly/3UYtQk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
tjdietderich said,
RT: @mattsingley: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/3UYtQk [Better DM controls = good idea.]
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
adreich said,
RT @mattsingley: How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs.
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
marcusnelson said,
RT @mattsingley: How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
geminijess said,
RT @mattsingley: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
technex said,
RT @Eliz_Castro: Twitter srsly needs to fix this spam problem, first getting weightloss now IQ messages all week long – http://bit.ly/3UYtQk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
JulieWalraven said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
6myth said,
RT @mattsingley How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
VAinParadise said,
How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/DqQw9
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
virtualblessing said,
RT @VAinParadise: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/DqQw9
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
opconf said,
RT @mattsingley How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
AlexSchleber said,
RT @mattsingley: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
mattsingley said,
How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
LAWeekly said,
ugh yes already RT @mattsingley How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
AndyWills_ said,
RT @mattsingley How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs Please RT folks
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
AmerikaG said,
Interesting idea: the ability to turn DM’s on and off while still following a person. Worth a read. http://ow.ly/zFIt
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
FunomenalRealtr said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE {he’s so smart!}
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
mawkus said,
RT @mattsingley: How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs (interesting)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RockyCoolCat said,
Not sure his solution is right, but good explanation. RT @FunomenalRealtr: RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix DM Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
TopBrokerOC said,
Not sure his solution is right, but good explanation. RT @FunomenalRealtr RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix DM Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
joshgroth said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
ckieff said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix DM Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Twitter_Tips said,
What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
LinkedMedia said,
RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS – gr8t insight!
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
rstbob said,
I’m sure if this is the ideal solution: RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
UltraText said,
RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
kats2009 said,
RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
addmy2cents said,
RT @Twitter_Tips What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
TheYTNstation said,
RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
TrendyDC said,
RT @Twitter_Tips What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
PDParker said,
RT: @TrendyDC RT @Twitter_Tips What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
dpbkmb said,
RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
julito77 said,
RT @tweetmeme How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE from the great @mattsingley LOVE THIS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
CronkiteJMC425 said,
RT @Twitter_Tips What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
cherluvya said,
RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
expansionexpert said,
RT @julito77: RT @tweetmeme How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE from the great @mattsingley
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
realestatetips8 said,
RT @cherluvya RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ http://bit.ly/3vOJQX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
WeBelieveTeam said,
What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS: What C.. http://bit.ly/3LVUlm
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
webrancher_ said,
How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam » Matt Singley | Social …: Dear Twitter,. You have done an incredible.. http://bit.ly/2AbMK8
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
lights_rage said,
RT @mattsingley How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
stirlock said,
rt @lights_rage: RT @mattsingley How @Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam [let's get this going folks!] http://bit.ly/3UYtQk #fixDMs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Grumpylolo said,
RT @Twitter_Tips: What Can Fix Twitter’s Big Spam Problem? Filtered DMs: http://j.mp/37XOeQ –Share: http://bit.ly/17zcQS
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
mminoru said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
SMMAlerts said,
Currently Reading: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/4yc8fL
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
TwiTuts said,
How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://twurl.nl/awvif4 #TwiTuts
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
paulbarrow said,
How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam, http://ow.ly/AHl1
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
mattsingley said,
Still getting a lot of phishing DMs, so time for a RT: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/JJT4e
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
jeffrago said,
RT @mattsingley: Still getting a lot of phishing DMs, so time for a RT: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/JJT4e
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Jayoutoftune said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
legaltypist said,
RT @mattsingley: Still getting a lot of phishing DMs, so time for a RT: How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/JJT4e
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
paulceaston said,
Simple solution to Twitter DM spam: http://ow.ly/BdSL (allow me to turn off DM for an account w/o having to unfollow, like SMS notification)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
TargetStars said,
How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/2tfMd0
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
johnflurry said,
Reading @mattsingley’s How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
LiLMiSS412 said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
kojiokada said,
How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://mattsingley.com/blog/2009/11/how-twitter-can-fix-direct-message-spam/
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
NewAssetClass said,
RT @mattsingley How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
NewAssetClass said,
How to Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE AND SEE http://tr.im/dm_spam
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
steely_den said,
RT @tweetmeme How Twitter Can Fix Direct Message Spam http://bit.ly/46ejaE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Add A Comment